Choosing the right grill can feel overwhelming with so many options available. Gas, charcoal, pellet, or electric? Portable or full-size? Budget-friendly or premium investment? This guide breaks down everything you need to know to find your perfect grill match.
We'll cover the pros and cons of each grill type, help you understand space and capacity requirements, and recommend the best grills at every price point.
Types of Grills
Gas Grills
Best for: Convenience and quick cooking
Gas grills offer the fastest heat-up time and easiest temperature control. Perfect for weeknight dinners and beginners. Look for stainless steel burners, BTU ratings (20,000+ for two burners), and cast iron grates.
- Pros: Quick start, easy temperature control, consistent heat
- Cons: Less smoky flavor, requires propane or natural gas
Charcoal Grills
Best for: Traditional BBQ flavor and high heat
Charcoal grills deliver authentic smoky flavor and can reach higher temperatures than gas. The Weber Kettle remains the gold standard for reliability. Ceramic kamado grills like Big Green Egg offer superior heat retention.
- Pros: Authentic flavor, high heat capability, portable
- Cons: Longer setup time, temperature control learning curve
Pellet Grills
Best for: Set-it-and-forget-it smoking and grilling
Pellet grills use wood pellets for fuel, combining gas convenience with wood-fired flavor. Digital controls maintain precise temperatures. Great for low-and-slow smoking as well as high-heat grilling.
- Pros: Wood flavor, precise temp control, versatile cooking
- Cons: Requires electricity, pellet costs, complex mechanics
Electric Grills
Best for: Apartments and condos with restrictions
Electric grills are perfect when open flames aren't allowed. Modern electric grills deliver surprisingly good results. No smoke or flare-ups, making them ideal for balconies and indoor use.
- Pros: No fuel needed, apartment-friendly, easy cleanup
- Cons: Limited flavor development, requires power outlet
Space & Size Considerations
Balcony Grilling
Check your apartment rules first—many allow electric grills but prohibit gas or charcoal. Look for compact models under 300 sq. in. cooking area. Weber Q2400 (electric) is ideal. Verify clearance requirements before purchasing.
Patio & Deck
Medium-sized grills (300-500 sq. in.) work well. Consider a two-burner gas grill like Weber Spirit II or a 22" kettle grill. Ensure at least 3 feet of clearance from house and railings. Grill mats protect deck surfaces from grease.
Large Backyard
Go as big as your budget allows. Three+ burner gas grills, large pellet smokers, or kamado grills are excellent choices. Consider features like side burners, rotisseries, and prep areas. Permanent outdoor kitchen setups become viable.
Capacity Guide
| Group Size | Cooking Area | Recommended Grill Size |
|---|---|---|
| 1-2 people | 200-300 sq. in. | Portable or small electric |
| 3-4 people | 300-400 sq. in. | Two-burner gas or 22" kettle |
| 5-8 people | 400-600 sq. in. | Three-burner gas or large pellet |
| 9+ people | 600+ sq. in. | Four+ burner or commercial-size |
Budget Planning
Under $200
Entry-level options including Weber Kettle charcoal, portable gas grills, and basic electric models. Great for testing if you enjoy grilling.
$200-$500
Sweet spot for quality and value. Weber Spirit II gas grills, mid-range charcoal, and entry pellet grills. Better materials and warranties.
$500-$1,000
Premium territory with Weber Genesis, quality pellet grills like Traeger Pro 575. Stainless steel construction and advanced features.
$1,000+
Top-tier grills built to last decades. Big Green Egg kamados, Napoleon Prestige, high-end pellet grills with WiFi control.
Match Your Cooking Style
Quick Reference
- Quick weeknight meals: Gas grill for fast heat-up and easy cleanup
- Weekend BBQ enthusiast: Charcoal kettle or pellet grill for authentic flavor
- Serious hobbyist: Kamado or premium pellet for maximum versatility
- Apartment dweller: Electric grill for flame-free grilling
Top Grill Recommendations
Weber Spirit II E-210
$400-$500
360 sq. in. cooking area, two burners (26,500 BTU), porcelain-enameled cast iron grates. Perfect for 2-4 people.
Weber Genesis E-325s
$900-$1,000
646 sq. in. cooking space, three stainless steel burners (39,000 BTU), GS4 grilling system, side burner, sear station.
Weber Original Kettle 22"
$150-$200
363 sq. in. cooking area, porcelain-enameled bowl and lid, One-Touch cleaning system. Classic charcoal flavor.
Big Green Egg Large
$1,000-$1,200
262 sq. in. cooking area, ceramic kamado design. Grill, smoke, bake, and roast. Lifetime warranty on ceramics.
Traeger Pro 575
$700-$800
575 sq. in. grilling space, WiFIRE app control, 6-in-1 versatility. Wood-fired flavor with digital temperature control.
Pit Boss Austin XL
$500-$600
1000 sq. in. cooking surface, flame broiler for direct grilling, digital control board. Best value in pellet grills.
Weber Q2400 Electric Grill
$300-$400
280 sq. in. cooking area, 1560 watts, cast aluminum body. Perfect for apartments and balconies.
Napoleon Prestige 500
$1,400-$1,600
760 sq. in. cooking area, four main burners (48,000 BTU), infrared rear and side burners, rotisserie kit included.
Key Features to Consider
BTU Rating
For gas grills, look for at least 10,000 BTU per burner. Higher BTU allows for better searing.
Grate Material
Cast iron retains heat best but requires maintenance. Stainless steel is durable and easy to clean.
Construction Quality
Stainless steel bodies resist rust. Thick-gauge metal holds heat better and lasts longer.
Warranty
Quality grills offer 5-10 year warranties on burners and major components. Premium brands offer lifetime warranties.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our testing and reviews at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products we've researched and believe in.